Cookie of the Year/2023

Cookie of the Year 2023 is the fifth iteration of the Cookie of the Year event, including Cookies that were released or obtained a Costume during 2023. The Cookie in first place will be awarded a Valentine's Day-themed Costume.

Round 1
The first round consisted of 52 contestants. They were sorted into groups of 12.

Round 2
The top 3 winners of each group in Round 1 moved forward to Round 2. The top 3 cookies of Round 1 Group A & Round 1 Group B were combined into Round 2 Group A, and the top 3 cookies of Round 1 Group C & Round 1 Group D were combined into Round 2 Group B.