Talk:Matcha Cookie/@comment-2601:283:4200:66DF:F56B:B60E:4531:DDC2-20181031223445

It says in Dark Enchantress Cookies description that “A dose of concentrated dark magic and poisonous scarlet pomegranate syrup gives this Cookie a deliciously evil taste”, so either of those could be the missing ingredient. I’m betting on the pomegranate juice.