Board Thread:Topic of the Month/@comment-38949743-20190622075747

So when we had the ability to make cakes, giving a cookie one would give 15 Affection. But now if we want an easy 15 affection with a cookie a day, we need to find out what gifts make them like us.

It seems that a cookie is willing to provide hints towards what they like sometimes, but otherwise it could be a lot of trial and error in finding what they like. So far I've only found two, but I'm willing to try and compile a list of all the Ingredients cookies like being given, since I can't find a list out there in internet land.

Good news! As of 11/30/2018, every cookie that was in the game has their Favorite Ingredient accounted for!

Thank you anyone who provided what you know about a cookies Favorites, even if it wasn't particularly finding their favorite.

Now this is not the end of gathering information, because new cookies will always be released. I hope, when they do come, someone will be ready to find out what it is that brings us closer to these cookies.

And of course, if there need to be any corrections made to an existing known favorite, or it turns out a cookie likes more than just their current confirmed favorite and Magic Candy ingredient, I'll be sure to add it in.

Below you will find every cookies favorite gifts to receive.

All Cookies

Magic Candy Ingredients (only applicable to cookies who have a Magic Candy. Please refer to the ingredient in parenthesis. Newer cookies do not seem to apply, starting from Snow Sugar Cookie's Magic Candy addition.)

Anniversary Cake (only until December 31st 2018)

Royal Golden Dough (Royal Club members only. Gives 50 Affection.)

Commons

Gingerbrave: Crimson Sugar Crystal

Gingerbright: Yellow Sugar Crystal

Strawberry Cookie: Pink Sugar Crystal

Skater Cookie: Rescue Certificate

Rares

Vampire Cookie: Solid Crimson Sugar Crystal

Pilot Cookie: Bronze Piece of Paper

Devil Cookie: Solid Gray Sugar Crystal

Zombie Cookie: Ancient Pet Egg

Pistachio Cookie: Silver Hammer

Alchemist Cookie: Ancient Cookie Chest

Princess Cookie: Bent Golden Key

Knight Cookie: Solid Pink Sugar Crystal

Gumball Cookie: Silver Paper

Cheesecake Cookie: Mysterious Golden Pouch

Muscle Cookie: Bronze Hammer (Iron Chocolate)

Cherry Cookie: Broken Key Fragment (Explosive Cherry Powder)

Cheerleader Cookie: Blessing Powder (Mint & Lemon Ribbon)

Rockstar Cookie: Silver Ink (Rock Spirit Guitar String)

Soda Cookie: Blue Sugar Crystal (Small Soda Wave)

Ninja Cookie: Solid Blue Sugar Crystal (Polished Shuriken)

Angel Cookie: Blessing Bowder (Blessed Feather)

Epics

Cocoa Cookie: Solid Brown Sugar Crystal

Wizard Cookie: Ancient Pet Egg (Popping Ice Cream)

Snow Sugar Cookie: Bent Silver Key

Peppermint Cookie: Bronze Ink

Kiwi Cookie: Rescue Certificate

Pancake Cookie: Pale Cube

Mint Choco Cookie: Silver Piece of Paper

Hero Cookie: Bronze Hammer (Energy Mineral Mint)

Space Doughnut: Mysterious Bronze Pouch (Mysterious Meteorite Shard)

Matcha Cookie: Solid Black Sugar Crystal (Enchanted Tea Leaf)

Fairy Cookie: Pale Leaf (Fairy Flower Seed)

Red Bean Cookie: Mysterious Bronze Pouch (Golden Beans)

Yoga Cookie: Mysterious Silver Pouch (Handful of Enlightenment)

Macaron Cookie: Blessing Powder (Rainbow Dough)

Herb Cookie: Blue Bottle (Sun-kissed Herb Seedling)

Avocado Cookie: Golden Hammer (Fresh Avocado Oil)

Mustard Cookie: Bronze Ink (Spiky Mutant Mustard Seeds)

Dr. Wasabi Cookie: Broken Key Fragment (Fresh Wasabi Mandrake)

Ice Candy Cookie: Breakout Certificate (Cracked Candy Puck)

Werewolf Cookie: Solid Black Sugar Crystal (Ash Moonstone)

Creampuff Cookie: Golden Ink (Puffy Little Cream Puffs)

Moon Rabbit Cookie: Mysterious Silver Pouch (Splendid Moon Rice Cake)

Carol Cookie: Green Sugar Crystal (Wonderful Melody)

Tiger Lily Cookie: Solid Orange Sugar Crystal (Sharp Tiger Orange Stone)

Skating Queen Cookie: Black Sugar Crystal (Snowflake-shaped Gem)

Pink Choco Cookie: Solid Pink Sugar Crystal (Melted Chocolate)

Orange Cookie: Solid Orange Sugar Crystal (Fresh Orange Slice)

Sparkling Cookie: Orange Sugar Crystal (Fizzy Ice Ball)

Cherry Blossom Cookie: Pink Sugar Crystal (Pink Cherry Sprout)

Whipped Cream Cookie: Solid Green Sugar Crystal (Lovely Toeshoe)

White Choco Cookie: Mysterious Golden Pouch (Hankerchief a la Rose)

Adventurer Cookie: Bent Golden Key (Baumkuchen Rope)

Blackberry Cookie: Gray Sugar Crystal (Gloomy Blackberry)

Chili Pepper Cookie: Mysterious Golden Pouch (Crimson Bandana)

Dark Choco Cookie: Solid Violet Sugar Crystal (Dark Cocoa Bean)

Red Pepper Cookie: Solid Crimson Sugar Crystal (Hand Wraps of Dedication)

Grapefruit Cookie: Breakout Certificate (Juicy Grapefruit Slice)

Lemon Cookie: Pale Cube (Charged Lemon Slice)

Salt Cookie: Broken Key Fragment (Salt Ore)

Pirate Cookie: Treasure Stamp (Old Treasure Map)

Lime Cookie: Solid Blue Sugar Crystal (Bitter Lime Piece)

Squid Ink Cookie: Cracked Treasure Stone (Ink-stained Coin)

Kumiho Cookie: Bent Bronze Key (Fluffy Foxtail)

Pomegranite Cookie: Solid Crimson Sugar Crystal (Mystic Bell)

DJ Cookie: Black Sugar Crystal (Sprouted Jelly Bean)

Rollcake Cookie: Golden Hammer (Caramel Wrench)

Popcorn Cookie: Solid Yellow Sugar Crystal (Freshly Roasted Popcorn)

Marshmallow Cookie: Yellow Sugar Crystal (Sugar Shako)

Cinnamon Cookie: Ancient Treasure Chest (Magic Card)

Fig Cookie: Solid Green Sugar Crystal (Green Fig)

Cotton Candy Cookie: Golden Ink (Fluff of Love)

Carrot Cookie: Brown Sugar Crystal (Mini Carrot Trowel)

Beet Cookie: Crimson Sugar Crystal (Vitamin Leaf)

Purple Yam Cookie: Bronze Hammer (Spiked Sweet Potato)

Milk Cookie: Blue Bottle (Calcium Rich Milk)

Ion Cookie Robot: Ancient Pet Egg (Powered Ion Drink)

Cyborg Cookie: Ancient Treasure Chest (Chewy Jelly Cable)

Dino-Sour Cookie: Solid Crimson Sugar Crystal (Sour Dinosaur Egg)

Legendaries

Sea Fairy Cookie: Millennial Tree Tears

Fire Spirit Cookie: Solid Crimson Sugar Crystal

Dark Enchantress Cookie: Cracked Treasure Stone

Wind Archer Cookie: Pale Leaf

Millennial Tree Cookie: Shiny Sugar Crystal (also likes Millennial Tree Tears)

Moonlight Cookie: Mysterious Golden Pouch (Little Star)

Special Characters

Mimmy: Solid Yellow Sugar Crystal

Hello Kitty: Solid Pink Sugar Crystal 