Talk:Peppermint Cookie/@comment-46142904-20200701000830/@comment-46142904-20200701001848

Additionally, the "they" mention was simply in the video and not in the actual game. Peppermint Cookie's bios and costume descriptions still avoid pronouns. Unlike the pronoun purge in 2018 or Dark Choco turning male, they didn't go the extra mile to change it, usage of "this Cookie", and "the Cookie" still remain. The usage of "They" in the English translation is still exclusive to the update video and the old English translations, and not the actual current game.

Also be aware that the update video was using translations for what the game developers said, it would be weird to make a discrepancy between the translation and what they actaully said so they probably just said "they" for the sake of simplicity.

I believe that the infobox should change to "Unspecified" again, with a note or citation with the mentions of using "they" and Peppermint being male in the JP version. A video that isn't in the actual game holds no bearing to the game, similarly to other social media posts. They're not canon, just there for a purpose, either to inform or entertain.

Looking at your user page and message wall, I understand that you were nonbinary yourself and want nonbinary representation in the game, which is understandable. However, I just want to deal with the facts here and see my point of view here. I'm not transphobic, let's get that straight. However, I feel that there is a difference between facts and emotion, and I think you do as well. If you feel that it is appropiate to add Peppermint Cookie being NB enough and go as far to put it in the infobox and change some of the pronouns, then I believe that the wiki should also add the mention of Mic Mac calling Cyborg Cookie a male (and then correcting himself) in the livestream video as a mention in Cyborg Cookie's trivia.

I apologize in advance if I come off as abrasive or hurtful towards you, I just feel that this choice is wrong.